MM2 Godly Value List (September 2026): Every Top Godly Ranked + Trade Tips

There is no official MM2 value list — Nikilis has never published one — so every "value" you see for a Murder Mystery 2 Godly is a community-consensus number maintained by third-party trackers and trading Discords. That's exactly why prices move week to week and why sites disagree. This guide ranks the current top Godly-tier weapons by community value as of September 13, 2026, cross-checked across the two most-referenced trackers (Supreme Values and MM2 Calculator, both updated within 48 hours of publish), explains how MM2 "value" actually works, and covers the five trades that get players scammed. MM2 is still a top-tier Roblox experience: a direct Roblox Games API pull on September 13, 2026 shows 255,687 concurrent players and over 30.4 billion lifetime visits.

Quick answer: As of September 13, 2026, the highest-value Godly in MM2 is the Traveler's Gun at roughly 5,400–5,500 community value, followed by Evergun (~3,450), Constellation (~3,100), and Evergreen (~2,700). These four are the "supreme Godlies" — everything else sits below ~1,900. MM2 "value" is an abstract community unit, not Robux, and value sites can disagree by 30%+ on Chroma and low-demand items (top Godlies are currently closely aligned). Godlies drop at roughly 0.3%–1% from premium/knife boxes (community-estimated, not official); Chroma is about 10× rarer. Always trade inside MM2's own trade window — never "add value later," never trust a middleman.

Below: the full top-Godly ranking with numbers, the rarity ladder that determines what's actually tradeable, how to read a "clean" trade vs an overpay, the honest drop-rate caveats, and the scam checklist every trader should memorise.

What is a Godly in MM2, and where does it sit on the rarity ladder?

Murder Mystery 2 items climb a fixed rarity ladder, and only the top of it holds trade value. Use these exact words — the community will spot a writer who doesn't:

Common → Uncommon → Rare → Legendary → Godly → Chroma → Ancient.

• Godly is the tradeable premium tier — the floor of "real" value. Most of the market lives here, from ~200-value fillers up to the ~5,400-value Traveler's Gun.
• Chroma are the animated rainbow variants of certain Godlies. They are roughly 10× rarer than Godlies and sit far above them on value (the Chroma Traveler's Gun is worth tens of thousands, versus ~5,400 for the standard Godly).
• Ancient items are retired or limited event pieces that appreciate on a shrinking supply. Some value pages surface Ancient-tier items like Batwing and Black Luger at a placeholder 1,000,000 inside the "Godly" view — those are not normal tradeable Godlies and are excluded from the ranking below.

Values are quoted in an abstract community "value" number, not Robux. A knife worth "3,450" is worth 3,450 units of community value — a shared yardstick traders use to judge whether a trade is fair, not a Robux price tag.

MM2 Godly value list — top Godlies ranked (September 2026)

The table below ranks the highest-value Godly weapons by community consensus, showing both trackers side by side. The two lists agree on ordering and land within ~2–5% of each other on almost every item — a sign the top of the Godly market is stable right now. Values pulled September 12–13, 2026 from Supreme Values (updated Sep 13) and MM2 Calculator (updated Sep 12).

Rank	Godly	Supreme Values (Sep 13)	MM2 Calculator (Sep 12)	Tier
1	Traveler's Gun	5,400	5,500	Supreme
2	Evergun	3,450	3,450	Supreme
3	Constellation	3,100	3,150	Supreme
4	Evergreen	2,700	2,700	Supreme
5	Alienbeam	1,850	1,850	High
6	Vampire's Gun	1,850	1,850	High
7	Turkey	1,850	1,800	High
8	Darkshot	1,800	1,800	High
9	Raygun	1,800	1,750	High
10	Darksword	1,775	1,775	High
11	Blossom	1,370	—	Mid
12	Sakura	1,360	1,360	Mid
13	Sunrise	1,075	1,075	Mid

The gap at the top is the story. Traveler's Gun stands alone as the "supreme" leader, and the top four (Traveler's, Evergun, Constellation, Evergreen) form a clear bracket above everything else. Below rank 10, values fall off toward the four-figure floor and then into the hundreds for common Godlies.

The market has also moved since earlier 2026 snapshots. Traveler's Gun has risen from around 4,100 to ~5,400, and Evergun climbed from ~2,850 to 3,450 — both up meaningfully. That's the whole reason to date a value list: an undated MM2 number is almost always wrong within a month.

What are MM2 Chroma weapons worth?

Chroma weapons are the animated, rainbow versions of select Godlies, and they trade in a different league. For context on where the ceiling sits:

• Chroma Traveler's Gun — roughly 180,000–190,000 value (the single most valuable non-Ancient item; treat the exact figure as approximate and confirm on the live Chroma page before quoting it).
• Chroma Evergun — about 69,000 value.
• Chroma Evergreen — about 46,000 value.

Note the direction of travel: Chroma Evergun has cooled from 100,000+ earlier in 2026 down to ~69,000, and Chroma Evergreen has slid from ~69,000 toward ~46,000. Where the top Godlies are rising, several Chromas are receding — another reminder that these are live markets, not fixed price sheets. (Sources: Supreme Values Chromas, game.guide.)

How rare are Godlies and Chromas in MM2?

This is the least-official part of any MM2 guide, so read it with the caveat attached: Nikilis has never published a drop table. Every rate below is a community estimate from large-scale unboxing tracking, and sources disagree.

• Godly: community estimates range from ~0.3% (about 1 in 333) up to ~1% per premium/knife box, depending on the source. (mm2-value.com/rarity lists 0.3%; other trackers estimate closer to 0.5–1%.)
• Chroma: roughly 10× rarer than a Godly — community figures land near 0.03%–0.1% (mm2-value.com quotes ~1 in 3,333). Every source agrees on the ~10× ratio even when the absolute percentage differs.

The one solid, cross-source fact: Chroma is about ten times rarer than Godly. Treat any specific percentage as a community estimate, never as an official rate. That uncertainty is exactly why the trading economy exists — supply is genuinely scarce and unverifiable, so value is set by demand.

How do you read a "clean" trade vs an overpay?

Numbers on a value list are only half the picture. The other half is demand — how easy an item is to re-trade at its listed value. Three terms decide whether a trade is actually good:

• Clean value — a single high-demand item traded at its listed value with nothing sketchy attached. A "clean godly" like Traveler's Gun is easy to re-trade later, which makes it safer to hold than a pile of low-demand fillers that add up to the same number.
• Supreme value — the elite bracket of the very top Godlies (Traveler's Gun, Evergun, Constellation). It's a real term of art, not a generic synonym for "value."
• Overpay — giving more than an item's listed value, usually to secure something whose demand is climbing. A legitimate overpay chases a rising item; a weaponised overpay is the scam in the next section.

The practical rule: check demand and stability, not just the total. Two trades can be numerically equal and one can still be a loss if you hand over a clean, easy-to-move Godly for a bundle of falling, hard-to-trade items. Value sites like Supreme Values tag items Stable / Overpaid For / Underpaid For / Receding for exactly this reason — read the tag, not only the number.

The 5 MM2 trading scams to watch for

The most active corner of r/MurderMystery2 is players asking "W or L?" and "is this a scam?" — for good reason. Every one of these scams is defeated by the same habit: only ever complete a trade inside MM2's own trade window, and re-read both sides before you hit accept. Here are the five that catch people most:

• Fake middleman. Someone offers a "trusted" middleman to hold both items during a cross-trade — then the middleman vanishes with everything. MM2's in-game trade window swaps both sides simultaneously, so a legitimate trade never needs a middleman. If someone insists on one, walk away.
• Trust trade / "I'll add value later." "Send yours first and I'll add the rest after." Anything handed over outside the trade window is a gift, not a trade — you will not get it back. Real trades only complete inside the window, all at once.
• Last-second quick swap. A high-value item sits in the trade window to bait your accept, then gets swapped for a similar-looking cheaper item right before you confirm. Defence: re-read every item name on both sides immediately before hitting accept.
• Fake overpay. An offer that looks like a huge overpay to rush you — but the items are low-demand, receding, and hard to re-trade. Defence: check each item's demand and stability tag on a value site, not just the value total.
• Fake proof / screenshot fakes. Doctored inventory screenshots, or a trader who refuses to show the item live in-game. Defence: make them join a server and show the item in their real inventory before you commit.

None of these work against a trader who slows down and uses the trade window correctly. Scams rely on urgency — remove the urgency and they fall apart.

Where do MM2 values come from, and why do sites disagree?

There is no official value list for any Roblox experience, MM2 included. Values are community-consensus estimates maintained by third-party trackers (Supreme Values, MM2 Calculator, mm2values.app, Traderie) and trading Discords, and they update on different schedules with different methods.

That's why sites disagree. Right now the divergence is smallest on top Godlies (Supreme Values and MM2 Calculator are within ~5% on the whole top 10) and largest on Chroma and thin, low-demand items, where a single site can be 30%+ off another. The safe habit: compare at least two value lists and note the date each was updated before you trade. A price with no date is a guess.

FAQ

What is the most valuable Godly in MM2 right now? As of September 13, 2026, the Traveler's Gun is the highest-value Godly at roughly 5,400–5,500 community value, ahead of Evergun (~3,450) and Constellation (~3,100). These are community estimates, not official prices, and they move weekly.

Is MM2 value the same as Robux? No. MM2 "value" is an abstract community-consensus number used to judge whether a trade is fair. It is not a Robux price and does not convert directly to Robux or real money.

What's the difference between a Godly and a Chroma? Godly is the tradeable premium tier and the floor of real value. Chroma weapons are the animated rainbow variants of certain Godlies — roughly 10× rarer and worth far more (a Chroma Traveler's Gun is worth tens of thousands versus ~5,400 for the standard Godly).

How rare is a Godly in MM2? Community estimates put Godlies at roughly 0.3%–1% per premium/knife box, with Chroma about 10× rarer. Nikilis has never published official drop rates, so treat every percentage as a community estimate.

Why do different MM2 value sites show different numbers? Because there is no official list — each tracker maintains its own community-consensus estimates on its own schedule. Disagreements are largest on Chromas and low-demand items; top Godlies are currently closely aligned. Always compare two dated lists before trading.

How do I avoid getting scammed trading in MM2? Only ever complete trades inside MM2's own trade window, never "add value later" or use a middleman, and re-read every item on both sides right before you accept. Scams rely on urgency — slow down and they fail.

If you'd rather skip the RNG grind for a supreme Godly or a specific Chroma, our team can get the exact weapon you're after straight to your account.

⚡ Get the MM2 Godly you actually want — no unboxing grind:

• MM2 Godly Weapons — hand-pick the tradeable Godly you're chasing instead of gambling knife boxes
• All Murder Mystery 2 services — Godlies, Chromas, Ancients, pets, and weapon sets in one place

Live player and visit figures are from a direct Roblox Games API pull (universe 66654135) on September 13, 2026. All Godly and Chroma values are community-consensus estimates cross-checked against Supreme Values and MM2 Calculator (updated September 12–13, 2026); they are not official, they change frequently, and value sites disagree — verify today's number on a named tracker before trading. Drop rates are community estimates; Nikilis has not published official rates. timesaver.gg is an independent service and is not endorsed by or affiliated with Roblox Corporation or the Murder Mystery 2 developers.