Quick answer (TLDR): As of 2 October 2026, the most valuable tradeable item in Murder Mystery 2 is the Chroma Traveler's Gun (community value ~145K–220K), while the mythical Nik's Scythe sits far above everything as a near-untradeable showpiece (tracker estimates range from ~1.1M to 250M — the sites openly disagree). The rarity ladder, highest to lowest, is Ancient → Chroma → Godly → Vintage/Legendary → Rare → Uncommon → Common, and MM2 values are community estimates in in-game "value" units, not Robux or real money, and not official — Roblox and the MM2 developers (Nikilis) have never published a price list. Numbers below are cross-checked from community trackers on 2 October 2026 and move weekly; always re-check before a big trade.
Murder Mystery 2 is still one of Roblox's most-traded experiences — 30.97 billion lifetime visits, 24.3 million favorites, and ~212,966 players in-game at the time of writing (Roblox Games API, pulled 2 October 2026). That means a live, liquid trading economy — and a value list that shifts every week. This guide ranks every rarity tier, explains why the trackers disagree, and shows what's actually worth what right now.
Not keen on the grind? Timesaver runs a Blox Fruits boosting service that covers fruits, awakenings and race progress on your own account.
Roblox - Blox Fruits Boost
Get any fruit, awakened and ready
What is an MM2 value list, and is it official?
An MM2 value list is a community-maintained estimate of what each weapon, pet, and collectible is worth in trades — measured in abstract "value" units, not Robux and not USD. There is no official MM2 value list. As the trading-site RPGStash puts it, the list is "a community-based pricing system used to estimate trading values for godlies, chromas, ancients, and collectibles in Murder Mystery 2" (RPGStash, 2026).
That's why you'll see the same item quoted at wildly different numbers across sites. On 2 October 2026, Nik's Scythe — the rarest item in the game — was listed at 250,000,000 on BloxUltra, 125M on game.guide, and 1,100,000 on BloxSwaps. (For tier-specific deep dives, see our MM2 Godly value list and MM2 Chroma value list.) All three are "right" in the sense that nobody can actually buy one at a fixed price; it trades by negotiation, and the trackers are extrapolating from a handful of historic deals. Treat every number here as a ballpark, not a receipt.
Two rules make the chaos manageable:
- Tier order is stable; exact numbers are not. An Ancient will always outvalue a Chroma, a Chroma always outvalues its Godly base, and a Godly always outvalues a Legendary. The ordering barely changes week to week even when the raw numbers swing 30%+.
- Demand matters as much as rarity. Trackers publish a "demand" score (roughly 1–11). A high-demand Godly can out-trade a low-demand Chroma even though Chroma is the higher tier.
What is the MM2 rarity ladder (highest to lowest)?
From most to least valuable, the tiers are:
| Tier | What it is | Rough value band (2 Oct 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Ancient | The top showcase tier — ex-event mythics, mostly untradeable or near-untradeable | 16K → 250M+ (extreme spread) |
| Chroma | Animated/rainbow versions of Godlies; the real top of the tradeable market | ~40K → ~220K |
| Godly | The workhorse rarity most trades are priced in | ~250 → ~5,000 |
| Vintage / Legendary | Older or lower-tier craft/shop weapons | ~5 → ~500 |
| Rare / Uncommon / Common | Base drops and starter items | near 0 → a few |
Chroma items are the "king of the real market" because they're the most valuable things you can actually acquire through trading. As one tracker summary described the Chroma Traveler's Gun: "If Nik's Scythe is the museum piece, Chroma Traveler's Gun is the real king of the tradeable market" (Earnaldo, Aug 2026).
What are the most valuable Ancient items in MM2?
Ancients are the headline tier, but most are effectively untradeable — you'll almost never complete a deal for one, which is exactly why the trackers can't agree on a number.
| Item | Community value (2 Oct 2026) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Nik's Scythe | ~1.1M – 250M (trackers disagree) | Developer-tier showpiece; near-untradeable |
| Gold Gingerscythe | ~500M (where listed) | Event ancient, extreme spread |
| Gingerscope | ~16,250 (BloxUltra) | More commonly quoted ancient |
| Traveler's Axe | ~8,000 (BloxUltra) | Lower-demand ancient |
Sources: BloxUltra and game.guide value pages, pulled 2 October 2026. The 200×+ spread on Nik's Scythe is normal — there is no liquid market for it.
What are the most valuable Chroma items in MM2?
This is the tier that matters for most real trades. The Chroma Traveler's Gun has held the top of the tradeable market for months.
| Item | Community value (2 Oct 2026) | Demand |
|---|---|---|
| Chroma Traveler's Gun | ~145,000 – 220,000 | 9 (very high) |
| Chroma Evergun | ~56,000 – 74,000 | high |
| Chroma Evergreen | ~41,000 – 69,000 | high |
| Red Icepiercer | ~45,000 | high |
| Blue Elderwood Blade | ~45,000 | medium-high |
Sources: game.guide (Sep 2026), Supreme Values (Aug 6 2026 — Chroma Traveler's Gun "around 220,000 value with demand 9"), and timesaver.gg's August value snapshot, cross-checked 2 October 2026. For the full animated-tier breakdown, see our dedicated MM2 Chroma value list, and for the single hottest item our MM2 Icepiercer value page.
Roblox - Grow a Garden Pets
Get the pet you actually want
What are the most valuable Godly items in MM2?
Godlies are the currency of MM2 trading — most offers are priced in combinations of Godlies. Values here are far lower and far more stable than the top tiers.
| Item | Community value (2 Oct 2026) |
|---|---|
| Traveler's Gun (Godly base) | ~5,150 |
| Evergun | ~2,850 – 3,425 |
| Celestial | ~2,300 |
| Vampire's Axe | ~1,650 |
| Harvester | ~250 |
| Icepiercer | ~165 |
Source: BloxUltra MM2 value page, pulled 2 October 2026 (values shown in in-game value units, with per-item demand 2–5). See the full base-tier rankings in our MM2 Godly value list.
Why do MM2 value lists disagree so much?
Three reasons, and understanding them will save you from a bad trade:
- No official source. Nikilis (the MM2 developer) has never published values. Every list is a community estimate built from reported trades, so each site weights its data differently.
- Thin markets at the top. Ancients like Nik's Scythe trade so rarely that one unusual deal can move a tracker's number by millions. The rarer the item, the wider the disagreement.
- Weekly drift + events. New events (Halloween, Christmas, summer) inject fresh Chromas and retire others, so values shift every update window. A list more than a week or two old is already stale at the top tiers.
The practical takeaway: use value lists for tier ordering and ballpark ranges, confirm current demand on at least two trackers, and never accept a trade framed around a single headline number. When in doubt, trade in Godlies — the mid-tier is the most liquid and the hardest to get scammed on.
How do you get Godlies, Chromas, and Ancients in MM2?
- Godlies drop from Knife Box unboxing (the premium crate) at low odds, or from events and trading.
- Chromas are animated upgrades of Godlies, obtained mainly through events, special crates, or trading up from the Godly base.
- Ancients are almost entirely ex-event / promotional items — you get them by being there for the event or by trading, and the top ones barely move at all.
If you'd rather skip the grind-and-trade cycle, timesaver.gg carries MM2 items by exact tier with fast delivery:
Chasing a specific MM2 tier? Here's the exact route for each — no waiting on a lucky Knife Box or a risky trade.
- MM2 Event Chroma Weapons — the top of the tradeable market (Traveler's Gun, Evergun, Evergreen tier)
- MM2 Ancient Weapons — the showcase tier
- MM2 Godly Weapons — the trading-currency rarity
- MM2 Vintage & Legendary Weapons — older and lower-tier sets
- MM2 Pets — collectible companions
- All Murder Mystery 2 items — the full MM2 catalog
FAQ
What is the most valuable item in MM2 right now? The rarest is Nik's Scythe, an Ancient-tier showpiece that trackers value anywhere from ~1.1M to ~250M (they disagree because it almost never trades). The most valuable item you can actually trade for is the Chroma Traveler's Gun, around 145K–220K community value as of 2 October 2026.
Are MM2 values in Robux or real money? Neither. MM2 values are abstract community "value" units used only to compare items in trades. They are not Robux, not USD, and not official — there is no MM2 store price for Godlies, Chromas, or Ancients.
Is there an official MM2 value list? No. Nikilis has never published one. Every value list (BloxUltra, Supreme Values, game.guide and others) is a community estimate built from reported trades, which is why the same item shows different numbers on different sites.
What's the MM2 rarity order from best to worst? From highest to lowest: Ancient → Chroma → Godly → Vintage/Legendary → Rare → Uncommon → Common. This ordering is stable even when the raw value numbers swing week to week.
Why do two value sites show totally different prices for the same knife? Because the markets are thin and there's no official source. The top tiers (Ancients) trade so rarely that one odd deal can move a tracker's number by millions, and each site weights its trade data differently. Use the lists for tier order and ballpark ranges, not exact prices.
How often do MM2 values change? The top of the list drifts weekly, and events (Halloween, Christmas, summer) reshuffle Chroma values every update window. Treat any list older than a week or two as stale at the high end.
