Quick answer (TLDR): On November 15, 2026, Candleflame is worth 35 on MM2 Values and 30 on Supreme Values. It is a Godly knife tied for 53rd to 56th of 128 Godlies on MM2 Values, with demand 1.5/10. Chroma Candleflame is worth 40 on both lists, only 14% more than the plain knife, which is one of the smallest Chroma premiums in the game. Both came from the 2021 Halloween Box and can only be traded for now. A second item called Candleflame, a Rare gun from Halloween 2024, is worth only about 4 Tier 1 Rares. Values are community estimates, not official prices.
Candleflame is the purple candlestick knife from Halloween 2021: a black antique candle holder with a purple flame for a blade. It is one of the most recognisable Halloween Godlies, and with the Halloween 2026 event closing, it keeps turning up in trade offers. This guide gives you today's number from both value lists, explains why the Chroma is barely worth more than the plain knife, clears up the two items that share the name, and lists trades that come out even.
All values were pulled on November 15, 2026, around 09:30 UTC from MM2 Values and Supreme Values (read through the mm2values.app Candleflame page, because supremevalues.com sits behind a bot check). Item facts come from the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki. This applies to the current MM2 build in the final days of the Halloween 2026 event, which ends on November 16, 2026 at 18:00 UTC according to the game's official Roblox event listing. MM2 had 120,228 players online at the time of the pull, according to the Roblox Games API.
Not keen on the grind? Timesaver runs a Blox Fruits boosting service that covers fruits, awakenings and race progress on your own account.
Roblox - Blox Fruits Boost
Get any fruit, awakened and ready
How much is Candleflame worth in MM2?
Candleflame is worth 35 on MM2 Values and 30 on Supreme Values. That is the quick answer for a trade check. The detail below matters when a deal is close.
| Item | MM2 Values | Supreme Values | Demand (MM2V) | Stability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Candleflame (Godly knife) | 35 | 30 | 1.5/10 | Stable |
| Chroma Candleflame | 40 | 40 | 1/10 | Stable |
| Candleflame (Rare gun, 2024) | ~4 Tier 1 Rares | ~3 Tier 1 Rares | — | — |
| Elderwood Scythe (Ancient) | 40 | — | 1.5/10 | Stable |
| Harvester (Ancient, same event) | 270 | — | 3/10 | — |
Pulled November 15, 2026. MM2 Values from mm2values.com; Supreme figures as shown on mm2values.app; Rare gun values from the MM2 Wiki infobox.
The two lists are 14% apart on the plain knife. Supreme recently cut Candleflame by 3, from 33 to 30, and the MM2 Wiki infobox still shows the old 33. MM2 Values has held it at 35 at every snapshot since September 26, 2026, according to mm2values.app's change log. When the lists split like this, the fair price usually sits between them, around 32 to 33. Agree on one list before you trade.
Where does Candleflame rank among MM2 Godlies?
MM2 Values prices 128 Godlies. 52 are worth more than 35, and four sit exactly at 35: Candleflame, Elderwood Revolver, Darkbringer and Iceblaster. That puts Candleflame in a tie for 53rd to 56th. mm2values.app lists it as 53rd of 128 and 215th of 1,044 priced items across every tier.
For context:
- The Godly median is 21, so Candleflame is worth about two thirds more than a typical Godly.
- Just above sit Red Luger (38), Phantom (37) and Spectre (37).
- Just below sit Sugar, Makeshift and Lightbringer, all at 33.
- The top of the tier is Traveler's Gun at about 4,800, roughly 137 times Candleflame.
So Candleflame is a solid mid-tier Godly. It will not carry a big trade alone, but it is a useful, liquid add. If you need the rest of the Godly tier, our MM2 Godly value list has every one.
What is Chroma Candleflame worth?
Chroma Candleflame is worth 40 on MM2 Values and 40 on Supreme Values. Both lists agree, which is rare. Supreme trimmed it by 2 at its last update, from 42 to 40. On MM2 Values it is tied for 31st to 32nd of 46 Chromas with Chroma Laser, and its demand of 1/10 is the lowest score any Chroma gets.
The striking number is the gap to the plain knife: 40 against 35, a premium of only 14%. Most Chromas trade at several times their base Godly. mm2values.app puts it plainly:
"When a chroma sits within a few percent of its base, the market is telling you it was never really rare." — mm2values.app, Chroma Candleflame page
The site names Chroma Candleflame and Chroma Elderwood Blade as the two Chromas with the smallest premium over their base. The middle Chroma on MM2 Values is worth about 1,700, so Chroma Candleflame trades about 98% below a typical Chroma. Do not value it like an event Chroma just because it glows.
Two practical points:
- Never swap it one for one with plain Candleflame. The Chroma is still 5 more on MM2 Values and 10 more on Supreme.
- Check the colour in the trade window. The plain knife has a purple flame. The Chroma has a black handle and a flame that cycles through rainbow colours.
If you would rather skip the trade hunt, our MM2 Classic Chroma weapons page lists Chroma Candleflame as an option.
Where did Candleflame come from?
Candleflame and Chroma Candleflame both dropped from the 2021 Halloween Box, which ran during the Halloween Event 2021 from October 23 to November 25, 2021. The box page says each opening cost 600 Candies or 1 Reaver Key.
What to know about that box:
- The Godly and Chroma odds were never published. The wiki lists both as under 1% and notes the exact chances "are unknown". Treat any precise drop rate you see quoted as a guess.
- The rest of the box was cheap. Commons such as Haunted and Cat had a 70% listed chance, then Uncommons, Rares and the Legendary Spectral gun at 5%.
- The box is gone. The wiki says the event weapons "were only obtainable during the event, meaning they are now only obtainable through trading."
Candleflame was designed by IDontHaveAUse, who modelled many classic MM2 weapons. The same event also gave out Harvester, the first Ancient gun, which is worth 270 on MM2 Values today. Our Harvester MM2 value guide covers it in full.
What was the Candleflame Glitch?
Shortly after release, players found a way to duplicate the new event items. The wiki calls it The Candleflame Glitch (2021). It hit Candleflame, Chroma Candleflame and Harvester.
The wiki's account, in short:
- Nikilis patched it quickly and players who duped items were banned.
- The Candleflame page adds that he banned players holding ten or more Candleflames, but notes this "seems to have been removed", since players own ten or more today.
- The glitch page concludes that the items were "barely affected by this glitch as it was quickly patched".
So the glitch is a piece of trading history, not the reason Candleflame is cheap today. Its price comes from ordinary supply and low demand, which the next section shows.
Roblox - Grow a Garden Pets
Get the pet you actually want
Is Candleflame in high demand right now?
No. Demand is 1.5/10 on MM2 Values, and the trade data agrees.
mm2values.app counted 3,985 trade posts on its MM2 Trade Hub over the last 30 days:
| Item | Offered | Asked for | Most traded rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Candleflame | 26 | 13 | #86 of 504 |
| Chroma Candleflame | 45 | 11 | #67 of 504 |
Both are offered far more often than they are requested. For the Chroma it is about 4 offers for every request. The site's summary for both items is the same: "More traders are offering Candleflame than asking for it, so buyers have the upper hand."
What people ask for in return tells you where holders want to go:
- Candleflame holders most often ask for Candy (7 posts), Sakura (3) and Sunset (2). Candy is 90, Sunset 650 and Sakura 1,150 on MM2 Values, so these are upgrade attempts that need big adds.
- Chroma Candleflame holders ask for Heart Wand (3), Bat (2) and Heartblade (2). Heartblade at 65 is the only realistic one; Bat is 130 and Heart Wand 350.
If you are buying, this is a good market for you. Do not pay over list for either item.
Are there two different Candleflames in MM2?
Yes, and mixing them up is the most expensive mistake you can make with this name. Halloween 2024 added a Candleflame gun, a Rare item, not a Godly.
| Candleflame (knife) | Candleflame (gun) | |
|---|---|---|
| Rarity | Godly | Rare |
| Source | 2021 Halloween Box | Halloween 2024 battle pass, tier 17 |
| Cost at the time | 600 Candies per box | 12,800 Candies in total |
| Value | 35 (MM2V) / 30 (Supreme) | ~4 Tier 1 Rares (MM2V) / ~3 (Supreme) |
The Candleflame gun wiki page says it uses the default gun mesh with a purple finish and was "most likely inspired by" the Godly knife. The Chroma Candleflame page adds that the knife "has been partnered with the rare gun under the same name". That pairing is cosmetic. No value list prices them as a set.
Before accepting any trade that names "Candleflame", check two things: the rarity colour under the item (pink for Godly, green for Rare) and whether it is a knife or a gun.
What are fair trades for Candleflame?
These trades come out within a few points of even on MM2 Values as of November 15, 2026:
| You give | Value | For |
|---|---|---|
| Darkbringer, Iceblaster or Elderwood Revolver | 35 | Candleflame (35) |
| 2x Old Glory | 34 | Candleflame (35) |
| 5x Flames | 35 | Candleflame (35) |
| 7x Eggblade | 35 | Candleflame (35) |
| Elderwood Scythe or Chroma Laser | 40 | Chroma Candleflame (40) |
| 2x Watcher Gun or 4x Golden | 40 | Chroma Candleflame (40) |
| Candleflame + Chroma Candleflame | 75 | Sands (75) |
| Candleflame + Ornament | 95 | Candy (90), small overpay |
The stacks come from mm2values.app's calculator. A few rules keep these fair:
- Agree on the list first. On Supreme, Candleflame is 30, not 35, so a straight swap for a 35 item is a small overpay by that list.
- Elderwood Scythe for Chroma Candleflame is even on MM2 Values. Both sit at 40, which is exactly the swap players are posting about this week. The scythe is an Ancient and has slightly better demand (1.5 against 1), so it is the easier of the two to move on later.
- Do not chase Sakura or Sunset with Candleflame alone. You would need roughly 18 to 33 Candleflames' worth of value.
Our Elderwood Blade MM2 value guide covers the other Godly whose Chroma barely beats the base, and the Darkbringer value guide covers one of the three Godlies tied with Candleflame at 35.
Will Candleflame go up in value?
Probably not soon, though nobody can promise a price. Candleflame has one thing going for it: supply is fixed. The 2021 box is gone, so no new copies enter the game. That is why it has held flat at 35 on MM2 Values for seven weeks instead of drifting down like items still sold in shop boxes.
What holds it back:
- Demand is low. At 1.5/10 for the knife and 1/10 for the Chroma, holders outnumber buyers by two to four times.
- Christmas 2026 is next. MM2's Christmas 2025 event started on December 14, 2025, per the official event listing. New seasonal Godlies usually pull trading attention toward event items for a few weeks. Older Halloween items tend to stay flat or soften a little in that window. This is a pattern from past events, not a forecast.
- Supreme just cut it. The 33 to 30 drop suggests one list sees weaker real trades than the other.
For now, treat Candleflame as a stable 35 that is easy to trade away, and Chroma Candleflame as a 40 that looks far more expensive than it is.
Want Chroma Candleflame without trading up for it? Pick it up directly:
- MM2 Classic Chroma weapons (includes Chroma Candleflame) — delivered by trade in game
- All Murder Mystery 2 items — Godlies, Chromas and Ancients
FAQ
How much is Candleflame worth in MM2? Candleflame is worth 35 on MM2 Values and 30 on Supreme Values as of November 15, 2026. It is a Stable, low-demand Godly knife that has not changed on MM2 Values since September 26, 2026.
How much is Chroma Candleflame worth? Chroma Candleflame is worth 40 on both MM2 Values and Supreme Values. That is only 14% more than the plain knife, one of the smallest Chroma premiums in MM2.
Is Candleflame a knife or a gun? The Godly Candleflame is a knife. There is also a Rare Candleflame gun from the Halloween 2024 battle pass, worth only about 4 Tier 1 Rares, so check the rarity before you trade.
Can you still get Candleflame in MM2? Only by trading. It came from the 2021 Halloween Box, which was available during the Halloween 2021 event and has not returned.
Is Elderwood Scythe for Chroma Candleflame a fair trade? Yes, on MM2 Values both are worth 40. The Elderwood Scythe has slightly higher demand, so the person receiving it gets the easier item to trade on.
What was the Candleflame Glitch? A 2021 duping glitch that copied Candleflame, Chroma Candleflame and Harvester. The MM2 Wiki says it was patched quickly and the items were barely affected in value.
Values are community estimates from MM2 Values and Supreme Values and change often. timesaver.gg is not affiliated with Roblox or Nikilis, and neither sets or endorses these values.
