Quick answer (TLDR): On November 13, 2026, the MM2 Icecream knife is worth 140 on MM2 Values and 130 on Supreme Values. Chroma Icecream is worth 1,825 on MM2 Values and about 1,750 on Supreme, roughly 13 times the plain one. Both came from the 2026 Summer Box, which left with the Summer Event 2026 on August 23, so both are trade-only now. Values are community estimates, not official prices.
Icecream is the knife you keep seeing in MM2 trade posts. Its cone handle and Neapolitan blade make it easy to spot, and it is everywhere because the Summer Event 2026 that dropped it pushed MM2 to record player counts. That also makes it confusing to price: lots of copies, a falling value, and a Chroma version worth thirteen times as much. This guide gives today's value for both, explains why the price keeps slipping, and lists trades that come out even.
All values were pulled on November 13, 2026, around 01:30 UTC from MM2 Values (Godly list, Chroma list) and Supreme Values, read through the MM2 Trade Hub pages for Icecream and Chroma Icecream, because supremevalues.com sits behind a bot check. Drop odds and event details come from the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki. Event dates come from MM2's official Roblox event listings (Summer 2026). This applies to the current MM2 build during the Halloween Event 2026, which ends on November 16, 2026 (Roblox event page). MM2 had 173,211 players online at the time of the pull, according to the Roblox Games API.
Not keen on the grind? Timesaver runs a Blox Fruits boosting service that covers fruits, awakenings and race progress on your own account.
Roblox - Blox Fruits Boost
Get any fruit, awakened and ready
How much is Ice Cream worth in MM2?
Icecream is worth 140 on MM2 Values and 130 on Supreme Values. The two lists are 7% apart, so agree on which one you are using before you trade. Its MM2 Values price has fallen from 170 to 140 since early October, and trade posts offering it outnumber posts asking for it almost 8 to 1.
| Item | Tier | MM2 Values | Supreme Values | Demand (MM2V) | Rarity (MM2V) | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Icecream | Godly knife | 140 | 130 | 2/10 | 2 | Stable, falling since October |
| Chroma Icecream | Chroma knife | 1,825 | about 1,750 | 5/10 | 4 | Stable |
What the numbers mean:
- It sits in the upper third of the Godly tier. Icecream ranks 37th of 128 Godlies on MM2 Values and 159th of 1,035 priced items. The middle Godly is worth about 21, so Icecream trades at almost seven times a median Godly.
- It is tied at 140 with two other items: the knife Embersickle and the gun WaterGun. Borealis (135) and Sweet (150) sit just either side.
- Its listed demand is low (2/10), which is normal for a Godly in this price band. Bat, Candy and Borealis are rated the same.
- The in-game name is one word: Icecream. Searches say "ice cream," value lists say "Icecream." They are the same knife.
Why has Icecream's value dropped?
Icecream has lost about 18% since early October. MM2 Trade Hub's saved history shows MM2 Values cutting it from 170 to 155 on October 8, 2026. The list updated on November 10 now has it at 140. Supreme also cut it by 5 in its latest update, from 135 to 130.
The trade feed explains the pressure. MM2 Trade Hub counts posts on its site and app over the last 30 days, out of 3,963 posts. These are offers, not finished trades:
| Item | Offered | Asked for | Most-traded rank | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Icecream | 218 | 28 | #12 of 499 | heavy oversupply |
| Chroma Icecream | 28 | 8 | #93 of 499 | sellers outnumber buyers |
MM2 Trade Hub sums it up: "More traders are offering Icecream than asking for it, so buyers have the upper hand." For every post asking for an Icecream, there are almost eight posts offering one.
Our read on why: the Summer Event 2026 was huge. The MM2 Wiki reports that it drove the game to a record peak of 1.1 million concurrent players, and later 1.3 million, before a Roblox ban wave on bot accounts cut more than 500,000 players in under two hours. Icecream was the only Godly in the event's only box, so a large player base had a reason to open it. We cannot measure how many copies were unboxed, but more copies in circulation plus low demand usually means a slow slide, and that is what the lists show. This is our interpretation, not something the list maintainers have stated.
One thing in owners' favour: when Icecream is offered on its own, the median asking price is right at its listed value (62 solo offers). That tells you what owners ask for, not what trades actually close at.
Is Chroma Icecream worth more than Icecream?
Yes, by a lot. Chroma Icecream is worth 1,825 on MM2 Values and about 1,750 on Supreme, against 140 and 130 for the plain knife. That is roughly 13 times the value. Look for the rainbow glow before you accept anything.
Chroma Icecream ranks 19th of 46 Chromas on MM2 Values, right in the middle of the tier. Its neighbours:
| Chroma | MM2 Values | Demand |
|---|---|---|
| Chroma WaterGun | 2,300 | 4 |
| Chroma Icecream | 1,825 | 5 |
| Chroma Mortal | 1,800 | 5.5 |
| Chroma Treat | 1,800 | 4.5 |
| Chroma Ornament | 1,800 | 3 |
| Chroma Sweet | 1,750 | 4.5 |
Unlike the plain knife, Chroma Icecream has held up. MM2 Trade Hub logged MM2 Values raising it from 1,700 to 1,825 on October 8, then to 1,875 on October 11. Today's list has it back at 1,825, still above the 1,700 it held before October 8. Its demand score (5/10) is also much healthier than the plain knife's 2/10.
People who post a Chroma Icecream most often ask for Alienbeam (7 times) or Snowcannon (6 times). Alienbeam is a Godly gun worth 1,875 on MM2 Values, so that swap is close to even. Snowcannon (725) is far below Chroma Icecream on its own, so those posts are likely asking for Snowcannon plus other items. Our MM2 Chroma value list ranks it against every other Chroma.
Where did Icecream come from?
Both versions came from the 2026 Summer Box, the only box in the Summer Event 2026. MM2's official Roblox event listing ran it from July 23, 2026, 21:00 UTC to August 23, 2026, 21:00 UTC. The wiki notes that "It ended far sooner than any other summer events before it."
The box cost 120 Shells or 60 Gems. The wiki lists these tier chances. They add up to slightly more than 100%, so treat them as approximate:
| 2026 Summer Box drop | Rarity | Listed chance | About 1 in |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tourist, Sand, Duckies, Cherries | Common | 70% | |
| Neopolitan, Turtles, Floral | Uncommon | 18% | |
| Pier, Sunset | Rare | 8% | |
| Bubbles | Legendary | 4% | |
| Icecream | Godly | 0.2% | 500 boxes |
| Chroma Icecream | Chroma | 0.004% | 25,000 boxes |
These odds are wiki-reported, not published by Nikilis, the developer.
Shells came from quests. According to the wiki's Summer Event 2026 page, six daily quests for collecting Coins paid 120 Shells a day in total, and three weekly quests paid 360 Shells a week. That is about 10 boxes a week for a player who finished every quest. Over the 31-day event that works out to roughly 45 free boxes, or about a 9% chance of pulling an Icecream without spending Gems. That is our estimate from the wiki's quest table, and it assumes a full quest run every day. Players could also open boxes with Gems, so the real number of rolls varied a lot from player to player.
The knife itself, in the wiki's words: "The handle is an ice cream cone, with various toppings protruding from the guard. The blade is made of Neapolitan ice cream, with chocolate on the bottom, vanilla in the middle, and strawberry on the top." Do not confuse it with Neopolitan, the Uncommon knife from the same box. It is several rarity tiers below Icecream.
What are fair trades for Icecream?
All figures are MM2 Values numbers from November 13, 2026. Each trade lands within a few points of even. MM2's trade window takes at most 4 unique items per side, and trading needs level 10.
| You give | You get | Their total |
|---|---|---|
| Icecream (140) | WaterGun (140) | 140 |
| Icecream (140) | Embersickle (140) | 140 |
| Icecream (140) | Borealis (135) + Eggblade (5) | 140 |
| Icecream (140) | Bat (120) + Icebeam (20) | 140 |
| Icecream (140) | 4 × Candleflame (35 each) | 140 |
| Icecream (140) | Candy (90) + Red Luger (38) + Fang (12) | 140 |
A few notes on those:
- Embersickle is still earnable until November 16. It is a Halloween Event 2026 item, and MM2 Values marks it Fluctuating with a 135 to 150 range. It has been volatile: our own pulls had it at 250 on October 22 and 80 on October 30. Its demand (3/10) is higher than Icecream's, but WaterGun is the safer one-for-one if you do not want that swing. Our Embersickle value guide tracks it.
- WaterGun is the cleanest one-for-one. Same value, same demand score.
- Stacking small Godlies is fine, but some traders will not take four of the same item. Check before you send it.
Our Bat value guide and Candy value guide cover two of the pieces above in more detail.
Roblox - Grow a Garden Pets
Get the pet you actually want
What can you trade Icecream up to?
People who post an Icecream most often ask for an Icepiercer (37 times), a Harvester (19 times) or an Emberbow (18 times). Here is what each would really take on MM2 Values:
| Target | Value | Icecream plus | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Icepiercer | 165 | Laser (23) | about even |
| Harvester | 250 | Candy (90) + Swirlygun (18) | about even |
| Emberbow | 575 | 3 more Icecreams + Old Glory (17) | about even |
Icecream to Icepiercer is the realistic upgrade. A small Godly add closes a 25-point gap. Asking for a Harvester or Emberbow with an Icecream alone is an overpay request, and with buyers this scarce it will mostly be ignored.
Our editorial suggestion: because offer posts outnumber ask posts so heavily, expect to add a little when you trade Icecream up.
Will Icecream go up in value?
Nobody can promise that, and the lists do not point to a quick rebound. What we can see:
- Supply is fixed. The 2026 Summer Box is gone, so no new Icecreams are entering the game. That stops the slide from getting worse through new drops.
- Demand is still weak. Almost eight offers for every ask, and a 2/10 demand score.
- Summer items have a seasonal pattern. Our read is that summer weapons get more attention when the next summer event is close. That is a guess, not a forecast.
- Christmas 2026 has not been announced. As of November 13, 2026, MM2's official Roblox event feed lists Halloween 2026 as the latest event. Christmas 2025 started on December 14, 2025.
If you are holding Icecream to sell, the lists give no clear reason to wait. If you are buying, the imbalance in trade posts gives you room to negotiate. We will refresh this page monthly, and again when the Christmas Event 2026 is announced.
How do you get Icecream in MM2 now?
You have two routes:
- Trade for it. Use the table above. WaterGun or Embersickle is an even one-for-one, and with so many Icecreams on offer you should not have to overpay.
- Buy it from a marketplace. Our MM2 Godly weapons page stocks Icecream, and our event Chroma weapons page stocks Chroma Icecream, both delivered by a normal in-game trade.
You cannot unbox it anymore. The 2026 Summer Box left with the event on August 23, 2026. New to trading? Our guide on how to get Godly weapons in MM2 covers the tiers and how the trade window works, and the MM2 Godly value list ranks every Godly.
The Summer Box is gone, so trading or buying is the only way to get Icecream now. Pick one up directly:
- MM2 Godly Weapons (includes Icecream): delivered by in-game trade
- All Murder Mystery 2 items: Godlies, Chromas and Ancients
FAQ
How much is Ice Cream worth in MM2? On November 13, 2026, Icecream is worth 140 on MM2 Values and 130 on Supreme Values. MM2 Values had it at 170 until October 8, 2026.
How much is Chroma Icecream worth? Chroma Icecream is worth 1,825 on MM2 Values and about 1,750 on Supreme Values, roughly 13 times the plain Icecream.
Is Icecream rare in MM2? Not very. It dropped at 0.2% from the 2026 Summer Box, about 1 in 500 boxes, during MM2's biggest event. Its rarity score on MM2 Values is 2, and it is the 12th most-traded item on MM2 Trade Hub.
Can you still get Icecream in MM2? Only by trading or buying it. The 2026 Summer Box was only available during the Summer Event 2026, which ended on August 23, 2026.
What is Icecream worth in trades? It is an even swap for WaterGun or Embersickle, both 140. Add a small Godly like a Laser to trade it up to an Icepiercer (165).
Is Icecream the same as Neopolitan? No. Both came from the 2026 Summer Box, but Neopolitan is an Uncommon knife with an 18% tier chance. Icecream is the Godly.
Values are community estimates from MM2 Values and Supreme Values and change often. timesaver.gg is not affiliated with Roblox or Nikilis.
