Timesaver

FC 27 'You Already Have an Evolution Version of This Player': 3 Causes and the Fixes That Actually Work

Sam Okonkwo
Sam Okonkwo
FC 27 'You Already Have an Evolution Version of This Player': 3 Causes and the Fixes That Actually Work

FC 27 shows "You already have an Evolution version of this player." when you try to put a card into an Evolution and the game thinks your club already holds an evolved version of that same footballer. It isn't checking the specific card. It's checking the player. In most cases the cause is real: another version of him is already evolved, or the card still has an unfinished Evo. In the rest, the game is remembering an evolved copy you no longer own, which is a bug players have reported since FC 24. This guide covers EA SPORTS FC 27 Ultimate Team as of 17 November 2026, Season 2, with the Black Friday Thunderstruck promo from EA's Season 2 roadmap still to land.

Below: how to tell which of the three causes you have, what actually removes the block, and how to avoid locking yourself out before the next promo version of a player you like.

TLDR: the FC 27 Evolution version error in 30 seconds. The message: a "Warning" pop-up plus a red banner reading "You already have an Evolution version of this player." It appears on console and in the Web/Companion App. Cause 1, most common: you already own a different version of the same player with an Evolution applied. That includes the paid Roles++ Evos (7,500 coins or 150 FC Points) and cosmetic Evos. Fix: evolve that card instead, or use Remove all Evolutions on it (EA: "Removing an Evolution is final and can't be undone."). Cause 2: the card still has an unclaimed level or a running Training Camp. Claim everything first. Cause 3, the ghost: an evolved copy left your club, but the game still remembers it. FC 27 players report that Streamlined SBCs do not clear it. If you quick sold it, Quick Sell Recovery (7 days, 5 per 31 days) is the only thing that sometimes works. Otherwise it's a ticket to EA. Prevention: pick the version you'll keep before you spend coins on any Evo.

Coins

EA Sports FC 27 - Coins

Stock up on Coins

4.9· 2k+ ordersDelivery starts in minutes
Startingfrom $8.40Buy now

What does "You already have an Evolution version of this player" mean in FC 27?

FC 27 You already have an Evolution version of this player error: which of the three causes you have

It's a club-level rule, not a card-level one. FC 27 lets you own several versions of the same footballer, such as his gold rare, a TOTW, an Unleashed card or a Thunderstruck card. It only lets one of them carry Evolutions at a time. When you try to submit a second version, the game stops you with a Warning dialog and the same sentence as a red banner. Players have posted the identical wording from FC 27 on PlayStation, Xbox and the Companion App on r/fut and r/EASportsFC throughout Season 1 and Season 2.

EA's own Evolutions help page never spells the rule out. It covers entry requirements, time limits, removal and Repeatable Evos, but not "one evolved version per player". That gap is why so many threads read like bug reports when the game is doing what it was built to do. The rule isn't new. The same message has appeared since Evolutions launched in FC 24, and the FC 24 bug thread on EA's Answer HQ ran past 60 pages.

Three things trigger it. Check them in this order, because the first two can be fixed in a minute.

CauseHow to spot itFixFixable today?
1. You own another evolved versionClub search for the player shows a second card with the Evo badgeEvolve that card, or Remove all Evolutions from itYes
2. Unclaimed or unfinished Evo on this cardMy Evolutions shows a level ready to claim, or a Training Camp timerClaim every level, or wait out or cancel the Training CampYes
3. Ghost Evo historyNo evolved copy anywhere in your clubQuick Sell Recovery if it was quick sold within 7 days, otherwise contact EASometimes

Cause 1: do you already own another evolved version of this player?

This is the most common case, and it catches people out because of which Evos count. Any Evolution applied to a card makes it "an Evolution version", including the ones that barely feel like Evos:

  • Roles++ Evos. All 12 position Roles++ Evos cost 7,500 coins or 150 FC Points each. FC 27 players have posted the warning from inside the Roles++ RB and Roles++ CB Evo screens, with the "Start Evolution 7,500 or 150" button visible. One r/EASportsFC player described exactly that trap. They bought a card, gave it Roles++, then packed a different version of the same player. The packed card was locked out of both position Evos and cosmetic Evos.
  • Cosmetic Evos. Players report cosmetic Evos are refused on a second version just like stat Evos. The safe assumption is that a cosmetic Evo on one version counts like any other Evolution.
  • Free Training Camp Evos and Season Pass reward Evos. These count too, including anything you ran through a short Training Camp months ago and forgot about.

How to check in 20 seconds: go to Club > Players, search the player's name, and look at every version you own. The evolved one carries the Evolution marker and usually shows more than its base rating.

The fix depends on which card you want to keep:

  • Keep the evolved one? Then the error is doing its job. Run your new Evo on that card instead, provided it still meets the entry rules. Our guide to why a player is not eligible for an Evolution covers the OVR caps, the "Must not be" position line and the four self-inflicted blocks.
  • Want the new version instead? Open the evolved card's action menu and choose Remove all Evolutions. EA describes the process step by step and warns that it's permanent: "Removing an Evolution is final and can't be undone." You'll see a downgrade preview before you hold to confirm. The card goes back to your club as a plain item. If it was tradeable before any Evo, EA says it becomes tradeable again once all Evolutions are gone. Our Remove Evolution guide covers what you never get back, such as the coins or FC Points you paid to enter.

EA doesn't state whether "Remove all" lifts this particular block straight away. It's the only EA-documented way to turn an evolved card back into a normal one, which is exactly what the warning complains about. Don't use "Remove last Evolution" for this: the card stays an Evolution version until every Evo is gone.

Cause 2: is there an unclaimed level or a running Training Camp on the card?

If the card you're trying to submit is itself mid-Evo, players report the game refuses to start another one. According to r/EASportsFC posts from March 2024, EA closed an FC 24 Evo exploit by blocking players in unclaimed Evos from entering new ones. Go to Club > Evolutions > My Evolutions and look for:

  • A level ready to claim. EA's help page says your reward choice "is only locked when you complete the Evolution level and claim its rewards". Until you claim, the Evo is still open.
  • A Training Camp timer. EA: "When you submit a Player to a Training Camp Evolution, your Player is unavailable for a set amount of time." Training Camps run "from a few hours to more than 30 days". You can cancel one, but EA warns that "you won't get rewards for the remaining levels or receive back any FC Points or Ultimate Team™ Coins used to access the Evolution."

Claim everything, back out to the main Ultimate Team menu, and try the new Evo again. This is also the first thing to do before chaining. Several of this season's best routes depend on it, such as the free 83 chain in our Right-Hand Drive Evo guide.

One caveat: in FC 26, players on EA's forums reported the warning appearing right after finishing a Training Camp Evo (Birthday Brunch) on the very card they wanted to chain. Claiming is necessary, but it hasn't always been enough. If you've claimed everything and still see the error on that same card, restart the game fully before you treat it as Cause 3.

Cause 3: why does FC 27 say I have an evolved version when I don't?

FC 27 Evolution version error: what removes the block and what does not

This is the frustrating one. You search your club, there's no evolved copy anywhere, and the warning still fires. What players have reported across three games is that the server keeps an Evolution history for the player, and some ways of getting rid of a card don't wipe it.

What FC 27 players report, from the r/EASportsFC thread "Trying to evolve a player but it says he already has an existing evo when this is not true" (13 October) and later r/fut posts:

  • Streamlined SBCs don't clear it. A player put their old evolved card into a Gold Re-Roll Streamlined SBC and still couldn't evolve the new version. By May 2024, FC 24 players were reporting that a normal SBC submission did free the player. That doesn't appear to carry over to FC 27's score-based SBCs. (Our Streamlined SBCs explainer covers how those differ.)
  • Quick selling doesn't clear it. Quick selling the evolved card and buying the base card again hits the same wall. A widely shared r/EASportsFC explainer from April 2024 found the same: once a version had been evolved, quick selling it didn't free the player.
  • Switching device doesn't clear it. The error shows on console as well as the Web App.

What sometimes works: Quick Sell Recovery. If you quick sold the evolved copy in the last 7 days, recovering it brings the evolved card back. You can then decide between Cause 1's options with the card in hand. Players reported this working in FC 24, but results are mixed. An FC 26 player recovered the card and still got the error, and an FC 27 player found the card didn't even show up in the recovery list. EA's Quick Sell Recovery rules: up to 7 days after the quick sell, 5 recoveries per 31-day period, you repay the coins the quick sell paid you, and it runs in the Web and Companion Apps only. Full walkthrough in our FC 27 Quick Sell Recovery guide.

What doesn't work: SBC submissions. EA treats SBC submissions as permanent. There's no recovery, so the card can't come back.

When you're stuck, report it. EA's FC 27 Ultimate Team forum already has threads titled "You already have an Evolution version of this player" despite not owning one. Give EA Help the same details the long-running bug thread asked for, so the ticket can actually be checked:

  • Player name, rating and version you're trying to evolve, plus the Evo's name.
  • Whether you own any other version of the player.
  • Whether you ever evolved, quick sold, discarded or SBC'd a version of him, and roughly when.
  • A screenshot of the exact warning.

None of the FC 27 title update notes we checked, up to v1.2.0, list a fix for it. EA's v1.2.0 Pitch Notes list two Evolution fixes: a missing cancel option on multi-choice Evo confirmations, and a "+0" display bug. Neither is this one.

FUT Champions Boost

EA Sports FC 27 - FUT Champions Boost

Get fut champions boost in 10 minutes

4.9· 2k+ ordersFast turnaround
Startingfrom $3.15Buy now

Can you evolve two versions of the same player in FC 27?

No. Only one version of a footballer can carry Evolutions at any time. Owning two versions is fine, and so is using both in squads. Evolving both isn't. That matters more in FC 27 than before, because EA's FUT Deep Dive already gives special cards what an Evo used to:

"all special Items released throughout the year in EA SPORTS FC™ 27 will receive Role++ familiarity across every role in their primary and secondary positions"

So a promo version of a player arrives with the Role++ familiarity a Roles++ Evo would buy. Spending 7,500 coins on Roles++ for a cheap gold version of the same player can then block every free Evo on the better promo card when he gets one. That's the costly version of this error.

How do you avoid the Evolution version error before the next promo?

Season 2 still has the Black Friday Thunderstruck promo to come, according to EA's own roadmap. EA hasn't confirmed the date, and the leaked squad only carries predicted ratings (our Thunderstruck leak tracker is updated as cards are confirmed). Four habits keep you out of trouble:

  • Decide your keeper version first. If a player you like is likely to get a promo card, hold off evolving his gold card unless you're sure you'll keep it.
  • Never Roles++ a special card. It already has Role++ in every role at its primary and secondary positions. Use our Evolution Store breakdown to see which paid Evos are worth it.
  • Get rid of old evolved copies properly. Use Remove all Evolutions first, then sell or discard the plain card. Don't push an evolved card straight into a Streamlined SBC and assume the history goes with it.
  • Mind your slot count, not just your versions. Standard editions can run a set number of Evos at once. Ultimate, Ultimate Plus and EA Play Pro each add one slot (our Evolution Slots guide has the numbers). A full slot is a different block from this one.
SituationCan you evolve the new version?What to do
Gold version evolved, promo version packedNoRemove all Evolutions from the gold, or keep evolving the gold
Gold version with Roles++ only, promo packedNoRemove all Evolutions from the gold (the 7,500 coins are gone either way)
Old evolved version quick sold 3 days agoUsually noTry Quick Sell Recovery, then remove its Evos
Old evolved version put into a Streamlined SBCReportedly noReport to EA with the details above
Same card, Evo finished and every level claimedYesChain it, if it still meets the entry rules

Is it worth fighting the error, or just moving on?

If the blocked card is a long-term keeper, such as a Thunderstruck or HOF card you'll use into Season 3, it's worth giving up a cheap evolved gold to free it. The free Evos this season are worth far more than a Roles++ bump. If it's a short-term card, keep the evolved version you already have and put your Evo slot on someone else. There are plenty of free Evos running each week.

Short on time to clear Evo levels before they expire? Our pro players can play the matches for you. Coins can cover the squad upgrades so you aren't forced to evolve a version you'll replace in a week.

FAQ

What does "You already have an Evolution version of this player" mean in FC 27? It means the game believes your club already holds a version of that footballer with at least one Evolution applied. Only one version per player can be evolved at a time, so the new card is refused even if it meets every entry requirement.

Does a Roles++ Evo count as an Evolution? Yes. FC 27 players have posted the warning from inside the 7,500-coin Roles++ Evo screens. A card with only Roles++ applied still blocks every other version of the same player from Evolutions.

Does putting the evolved player into an SBC fix it in FC 27? Not reliably. FC 27 players report that submitting the evolved copy to a Streamlined SBC did not clear the block, unlike the FC 24 workaround. SBC submissions can't be undone, so try Remove all Evolutions or Quick Sell Recovery first.

Can I get the Evolution back after removing it? No. EA says removing an Evolution is final and can't be undone, and you don't get back any coins or FC Points you paid to start it. You can enter the same Evo again only if it's still live and the card still meets its requirements.

Can I evolve two different versions of the same player? No. You can own and play both, but only one can carry Evolutions. Pick the version you'll keep longest before you spend coins on it.

Is it fixed in the latest FC 27 update? No FC 27 title update so far lists a fix for the ghost version of this error. If it fires with no evolved copy in your club, report it to EA Help with the player, version, Evo name and what happened to the old evolved card.

Coins

EA Sports FC 27 Coins

4.9· from $8.40

Buy now

You may also like